[JDEV] File transfers

Michael Rothwell rothwell at holly-springs.nc.us
Fri Jun 7 05:52:41 CDT 2002


I agree that p2p is more efficient for any single transfer. However, if both
clients are firewalled, they can't talk to each other.

> Therefore, shouldn't it rather read "p2p file transfer not supported"
> (NATs, firewalls, etc.) - at which point I could fall back to p2s2p?

That's probably better, but the gestalt of the discussion at the moment
seems to be "server-assisted transfers are stupid," which is why I posted in
favor of server intermediation. You pointed out another way in which
server-assist might be advantageous -- distribution.

If p2p is the One True Answer, maybe we should ditch the jabber server
altogether and just chat over gnutella.







More information about the JDev mailing list